Skip to main content

Table 5 Patient-based results from meta-analyses and review studies on the detection of bone metastases in patients with prostate cancer

From: A prospective study determining and comparing the diagnostic accuracy of fluoride-PET/CT, choline-PET/CT, whole-body bone SPECT/CT and whole-body MRI for the detection of bone metastases in patients with prostate cancer

Modality

Study

Disease phase

N(s)

N(pts)

Pooled sensitivity (%)

Pooled specificity (%)

Comments

NaF-PET/CT

Evangelista et al. 2016 a

Mixed

8

318

95.5 (CI: NA)

77.4 (CI: NA)

One study was included with results for both NaF-PET and NaF-PET/CT (Even-Sapir et al. 2006)

One study was included with lesion-based results (Poulsen et al. 2014)

Wondergem et al. 2013 a

Mixed

7

236

86.9 (CI: 83.7–90.0)

79.9 (CI: 78.4–81.4)

One study was included with results of NaF-PET (Even-Sapir et al. 2006)

Choline-PET/CT

Evangelista et al. 2016 b

Relapse

4

289

88.4 (CI: NA)

96.6 (CI: NA)

11C-choline studies only. One study was included with lesion-based results (Garcia et al. 2015)

Shen et al. 2014 b

Mixed

5

205

87 (CI: 79–93)

97 (CI: 93–99)

Both 11C- and 18F-choline studies included

Wondergem et al. 2013 b

Mixed

6

277

85.2 (CI: 83.8–86.6)

96.5 (CI: 95.8–97.1)

Both 11C- and 18F-choline studies included

SPECT/CT

Evangelista et al. 2016

Mixed

1

97

96.4 (CI: NA)

94.2 (CI: NA)

Only one study was included

MRI

Woo et al. 2017 c

Mixed

10

1031

96 (CI: 87–99)

98 (CI: 93–99)

Mixed MRI protocols applied

Evangelista et al. 2016 c

Mixed

8

324

93.2 (CI: NA)

96.6 (CI: NA)

Mixed MRI protocols applied

Shen et al. 2014 c

Mixed

6

402

95 (CI: 90–98)

96 (CI: 92–98)

Mixed MRI protocols applied

  1. N(s) number of studies included, N(pts) number of patients included, CI 95% confidence interval, NA data not available
  2. aThe two articles summarised results for NaF-PET/CT based on 15 studies in total, but due to the inclusion of overlapping studies the total number of original studies was 10
  3. bThe three articles summarised results for choline-PET/CT based on 15 studies in total, but due to the inclusion of overlapping studies the total number of original studies was 11
  4. cThe three articles summarised results for MRI based on 24 studies in total, but due to overlapping studies the number of original studies was 16